alternarrative


On Fish, and Intelligent Bengalis
December 26, 2006, 7:19 pm
Filed under: Littéraire, Trivialities

This passage in Kiran Desai’s The Inheritance of Loss made me chuckle:

     ”It is strange the tutor is Nepali,” the cook remarked to Sai when he had left. A bit later he said, “I thought he would be Bengali.”
     ”Hm?” asked Sai. How had she looked? she was thinking. How had she appeared to the tutor? The tutor himself had the aspect, she thought, of intense intelligence. His eyes were serious, his voice deep, but then his lips were too plump to have such a serious expression, and his hair was curly and stood up in a way that made him look comic. This seriousness combined with the comic she found compelling.
     ”Bengalis,” said the cook, “are very intelligent.”
     ”Don’t be silly,” said Sai. “Although they certainly would agree.”
     ”It’s the fish,” said the cook. “Coastal people are more intelligent than inland people.”
     ”Who says?”
     ”Everyone knows,” said the cook. “Coastal people eat fish and see how much cleverer they are, Bengalis, Malayalis, Tamils. Inland they eat too much grain, and it slows the digestion — especially millet — forms a big heavy ball. The blood goes to the stomach and not to the head. Nepalis make good soldiers, coolies, but they are not so bright at their studies. Not their fault, poor things.”
     ”Go and eat some fish yourself,” Sai said. “One stupid thing after another from your mouth.” (pp. 81-82)

Stereotypes! I don’t know if I should blame my parents for trying to make me believe that eating fish makes people smart! I had to face much rebuke all my life for hating fish (the way they cook it in the motherland) — for which I apparently didn’t deserve to call myself Bengali!


8 Comments so far
Leave a comment

mmm fish. I must be Bengali.

Comment by Leila M.

I love fish and no matter what you say I’d agree with the writer ;)

Comment by Suroor

Okay, since there is always that halal.. zabiha problem, I have been eating fish a lot since I moved to Boston, but I don’t think that helped my brain at all. Or it may be that I am just too old to have any cognitive improvement/development. On another note, it is a big coincidence that you are talking about this book NOW. This fellow traveller on my flight to IL was reading this and the name of the author intrigued me (Kiran Desai). And now I really want to get this book!

Aaah.. Austin! Beautiful!

Comment by sabrina

i’ve been wanting to read this book FOREVER – and it got the Booker! are you enjoying it? ….i just finished Naipaul’s “House for Mr. Biswas.”

“But bigger than them all was the house, his house. How terrible it would have been, at this time, to be without it: to have died among the Tulsis, amid the squalor of the large, disintegrating and indifferent family; to have left Shama and the children among them, in one room; worse, to have lived without even attempting to lay claim to one’s portion of the earth; to have lived and died as one has been born, unnecessary and unaccommodated.”

I definitely recommend if you haven’t read it already. -A :)

Comment by Anonymous

This is a common myth in America also. Fish may be better for you in a number of health ways, but intelligence isn’t one of them. I eat lots of fish and look at me :)

Ya Haqq!

Comment by irving

Hey, I know you: You are a razakar!

Comment by Anonymous

I like fish:)
I dont know about intelligence, but my bengali friends had the most beauitful hair! everyone sed it was down to the fish they eat.

We have fish once a week in our house, I think we shud increase out intake [for the sake of my hair:P]

Comment by Bint Muhammad

fish is good for the heart and brain

Comment by Farhan




Leave a comment
Line and paragraph breaks automatic, e-mail address never displayed, HTML allowed: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <pre> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>